Aqua Resist - Waterproof Color Pencil

The eyeliner is too pigmented Took two days to get the color off

Must have eyeliner

Best black eyeliner ever. Doesn’t smudge, run or budge! 10/10. Been using this one for years. I don’t love the new packaging I miss the traditional pencil design but this one is easier to just twist up.

Everyday

Love this color and application. I have gray/blue eyes for reference.

Staple product

Perfect everyday eyeliner! Never dries out and lasts in my water lash lines!!

This eyeliner is “nothing” proof

Ugh. I purchased this as an alternative to the liquid formula, which dries out so quickly. The liquid formula will stay perfectly drawn, even if I’ve fallen asleep! The pencil does no such thing. Within an hour, it smudged all over my eyelid and even under my eyes. I was so embarrassed when I saw what I looked like in a mirror while out! I will never purchase this product again. asleep

Just bought this, so I haven’t been able to do a proper wear test, however from the amount I have worn it, it’s definitely waterproof and doesn’t smudge, and it’s pigmented. I’ve struggled to find good waterproof eyeliner pencils that I could use for my waterline without it smudging or not having pigment. This one has been really good so far, but I’ll Probably update when I get to do a proper wear test with it on.

Terrible experience

Don’t buy this. The pencil was dry and impossible to use, I just wasted my money

Was hopeful it would be similar to when I used B4

I used this product years ago-they discontinued the color I used but decided to come back and try again. Before I used a 5L-Green Bronze-so I bought a Forest and a Bronze thinking maybe I could use again. Not the color I was looking for; but when I tried it, it stays on

Couldn’t find better than this eye pencil

Doesn’t smudge or go anywhere under the eye after couple hours, but if wearing for longer definitely need to set with powder so it doesn’t smudge.

I like this product , I still waver on if I want to buy it again. I find it slightly aqua resistant but only if you blend it out or set it with shadow. I also find it really soft, I found that for that reason, it’s not worth using the sharpener because it breaks very easy so that was really disappointing.

So very disappointed!

I am so unbelievably disappointed with this eyeliner. I applied this liner, and within an hour it had smudged down to my bottom lid.

Must for eyes

I have used this eyeliner for three years now. It’s literally the best pencil eyeliner I have ever used!!! No need to use a sharpener, never ends.