Aqua Resist - Waterproof Color Pencil

Runs and smudges

This was my go to for years without issue. Never smudged no matter how hot and sweaty my face got, and even lasted when swimming. Not anymore. Now it smudges and runs and I have raccoon eyes in an hour. Great colors, but doesn't even last 2 hours much less 25.

Not waterproof at all

Not waterproof at all for 24H. The color started fading in just half a day.

Love/Hate Relationship

Unlike the rest of my older skin, my eyelids are very oily. I started using the Aqua Resist after two previous brands that worked for me discontinued their "stay put" eyeliners. My go-to in the Aqua Resist is the Iron, but I must still use it with a primer. The first couple of strokes brand-new go on so smoothly, and then they are very dry and difficult to apply. My real issue is that at least 75% of the Iron pencils that I buy break off, as soon as you start to apply it and/or try to sharpen the tip, such as the one that I opened earlier this week. The tips are much too thick and the sharpener is useless! I like the Bronze and Ivy a little better because they continue to go on smoothly; but, again, the tips are way too thick. I also find that those two colors flake way more. I continue with this brand more out of necessity than anything.

It broke

I like the texture and the color. But when I tried to sharpen it with the attached sharpener it brokeoff.

Worth every single penny.

This is one of the best eyeliner you’ll use. Very very very black,dries to a matte finish and smudge proof. 10/10

Not truly waterproof

I wanted a good waterproof pencil for tightlining and this was not it. It's fine for doing your eyeliner but I'm disappointed. I need a pencil that stays on my upper waterline and doesn't transfer to my lower waterline but that definitely isn't this one.

Simple Awesome!

For the last few years, I have been trying all manner of eye pencils to find one that will work on damp eye lids. The winner by far is the Aqua Resist!!!! My eyes constantly weep in some form so finding a waterproof AND water resist on application in an eye pencil was crucial. Nothing beats this product so far! I have stopped looking for anything better out there because this product is it!!

Great color application but doesn’t stay

LOVE the color saturation and how easily it glides on, but it won’t stay put on my lid or waterline.

A must have in my routine .. you won’t regret it

This is the best eyeliner I ever have .. it’s been 4 months.. it glides so smooth without any smudges and last whole day .

glides on nicely but broke on day two of use so i would not recommend.

Love with blue eyes

Love this color and the stay ability! Definitely will repurchase

Not good for eyes.

Loved the colour but Im trying to use it for my inner eye corner as a highlight and it wont go on. Works fine on my hand. Have tried wiping with rubbing alcohol but that didnt work!