They're Real! - Mini Mascara resestorlek

Good not great

All the length you’re hoping for, with a little more lower lid runoff than you would’ve expected at this price point. I guess I wish I didn’t buy this in the middle of summer.

Not the same

I’ve used this mascara for many years and have always loved it.The past several months I’ve had to throw each one away sooner because it dries out so quickly. It doesn’t have the same lash coverage. It’s also bleeding to under the eye. Time to change to something else.

Lengthening and no clumps

This is one of my favorites for natural looking lashes. Lengthens and no clumps.

incredible length

I love this mascara so much. it lengthens so much!

Honestly love the way this mascara makes my lashes look but it has toooo much fall out and ends up ruining my under eye makeup

Used to love but last order was dried out garbage, like other reviewers have mentioned. Should have listened.

Bad formula change!!

They must have changed their formula since I last purchased. Mascara ends up all under/around the eye within an hour of application. I'm constantly wiping my under eye. My coworker said it happened to her and several friends too. I will NOT be purchasing again, after being a faithful They're Real user for years!

It smears alot after a long day. Im disappointed they discontinued the primer mascara

Not what it used to be

I used this product for years, but Benefit has reformulated it and it smudges after an hour of wear now. I’ll have to move on -

Best mascara

This mascara definitely makes my lashes POP I don’t find that it is buildable, however, it doesn’t need to be. The result from one layer is separated, lengthened, lifted lashes that last all day. Only thing is that it takes a moment to dry so be careful opening your eyes wide as it will leave marks

Normally love but received a dried out one

I LOVE this mascara and never had an issue with it before but this time it dried out within a day or two? Wondering if I received an old sample or something :(

Dried out

I used this for years, daily, but when I got to my second tube in the 2 pack, it was dry. I didnt have it very long, but just over the return time, so I contacted Benefit and they told in other words, too bad. So I found a comparable one that works great. I got that info in a search! Way cheaper too.