Clean Line - Liquid Liner

This is pretty good, may be better on younger eyes

I have tried many different liquid liners over the years. I usually find the lines they create to be easy. This one by Ilia is easy enough to use and generally stays in place decently, but sometimes when I wear an eye crayon instead of an actual eye shadow, I get some transference. My favorite liquid eyeliner, which is no longer available, was the liquid liner in Lady Gaga's first makeup launch for Haus Labs.

Not long lasting or smudge proof at all. Would not recommend

Never get this one it’s like water

So bad never ever get it . It’s like water and after 1 month use of only a couple of times you have to press so hard for the color to come out so bad

started out great.....

Was recommended to me in store by someone who works there. I was trying to get the tarte one but they were sold out. At first I thought it was amazing. Went on nicely, stayed put, nice rich black. BUT after just a few short weeks it is so dryed out. It's weird because it feels like there is more product but it isn't coming out and my eyeliner is looking light and not sharp. I won't be re purchasing this. I should say that I do a pretty thick, sharp wing so I need more product than just doing a little lid lining.

You need this if you love a sharp eyeliner look

Best eyeliner. It gives a very precise wing and doesn’t bleed. Very clean ingredients as well for even the most sensitive eyes.

Nothing is in it

Nothing is in it. Maybe it's natural but totally not worth it.

Must have

I’ve always been a big fan of liquid eyeliner, and this might be my new every day product. It stays on from morning when I’m getting ready with my kids until I get home at night after work and wash mumakeup off. It goes on sharp and stays on no matter what the day brings me.

Dried up completely after probably 2 and a half weeks

Not a bad eyeliner but not my fav. Not super pigmented, I don’t find it last very long and application isn’t perfect. Hopes for more with the price but will probably continue to buy as I like using clean products.

Sooooo dry

This eyeliner dried out so fast, and smudges incredibly easily. I wanted a "clean" product, but this just isn't it. Definitely not worth the money.

DRIED OUT FAST, DO NOT BUY

DO NOT RECOMMEND. I only been using it for probably 3ish weeks and it's already dried up..... I was looking for a non waterproof liquid eyeliner because I have eyelash extentions and there aren't too many options so I was hoping this would work. I can normally use an eyeliner tube for months long but this pathetically lasted less than a month. From my experience, drugstore liqud eyeliner works better. I'm going to try the colourpop liquid eyeliner next

My favourite liner

All I have to say is I’m a very happy customer! I haven’t felt the need to look around to see what other liners are on the market!