Master Mattes® The Neutrals Eyeshadow

Nowhere near worth the price

I took a leap of faith and ordered this despite some mixed reviews. Unfortunately, I’m pretty unhappy with this palette. The excess powder and fallout I can deal with if the eyeshadows perform well, but they’re don’t. The colors are muddied when blended together and often blend away. I’m not sure what I could be doing wrong as I have the right brushes and used it with and without eye primer.

This product is the perfect matte finish that lasts throughout the day. perfect for office or date night. looks like you have a filter on if you apply correctly.

Perfect Matte Palette

Perfect matte palette for eyes over 65 yoa. Great natural look for daytime and buildable drama for nighttime. Stays on with no creasing. Love!

I would get it.....

I've tried using this palette multiple times and to no avail have I found it worth the money. the formula is dry and hard to blend and the shadows were so dry and brittle that the broke inside the pan just spilling out everywhere. The dryness was the worst on the last row of shadows. I'm saddened by it really.

Perfect everyday matte palette

I’ve been using this palette for a few weeks, and it quickly became my everyday essential. The mattes are smooth, easy to blend, and never chalky. The pigment is buildable — soft for daytime looks but can be deepened beautifully for definition. I love how the shades suit any skin tone and give that professional, clean makeup look. There’s no shimmer here, just pure, elegant mattes — perfect for sculpting the eyes or pairing with other palettes. The formula feels creamy, with almost no fallout. If you love natural glam and timeless neutrals, this is definitely worth it.

Really Great

This is one of the first eyeshadow palettes I’ve used where the browns don’t end up looking orange on me. I honestly haven’t had a problem with the fallout either.

Flabbergasted

The colors are just perfect, the consistency makes it so easy to blend. This pallet made go back to using eyeshadow everyday. I’m officially a Mario girl.

Pretty

I feel like this is such a good basic palette to have in my kit, the colours are beautiful and its super easy to work with. Definitely a staple to have when youre starting to explore eyeshadows better. The only reason why its 4 stars rather than 5 is the pressing could be neater. I think for a not so cheap palette it should be more presentable when it comes to my door.

Only used a few times so far

Giving it 4 stars as I’ve only used a few times since purchasing so not used all the shades yet. So far I love it. Decent pigment, not much fallout. The packaging is basic for the money, hoping it lasts & Mario makes it a little better in time.

Not great

I bought this product because it has such good reviews, but I find that it’s not as pigmented as i would like it to be. I had to dip in multiple times to one shade just for any colour payoff, and when i did there’s was TONS of fallout. I get eyeshadows so that, but i i would dip it in once and there was much more than my other eyeshadows have. In my opinion, there are in my opinion, there are much better neutral brown eyeshadow palettes. Save your money

incorrect product description

I bought this palette. I thought it was Karima and the texture was like the website said—creamy eyeshadow. But it turned out to be a drying texture. The website description was incorrect, which is a shame...

Really overhyped

I’ve tried so hard to love this palette and use it multiple times different ways, but it’s not worth the money. Good thing I got it discounted from FB marketplace but still. Don’t listen to the incentivized reviews, it doesn’t live up to the hype. No matter how I apply it or which colors I use, they always blend out into an ugly grey muddy color. I know they’re supposed to be neutral or cool toned but that doesn’t mean they’re supposed to all be greyish and ugly, even the white nude shade is ugly. The only redeeming factor about these shadows is they’re very blendable but that’s not real a pro when every time it blends into mud. The color story and color pay off/ pigmentation is terrible. Very dull muddy colors that do not last more than a couple hours. The dark brown is more of an ash grey. Not a hint of brown in there.